Posted by
rio
20 yrs ago
Troubled past and really need to talk to someone..
which one of the two should i go to?
Please support our advertisers:
rio
20 yrs ago
thanks Pumpkin.
i'll see what i can do...
Please support our advertisers:
Not all psychologists uses psychodynamic theory. There are many approaches, ie. Behavioural theory and approach for instance.
The main difference, is that psychiatrist can give out medication to 'help' out your issues
Please support our advertisers:
hkkm
20 yrs ago
There are other differences between psychiatrist, psychologist and therapist. A psychiatrist will have a medical degree plus postgraduate qualifications (that's why they can prescribe medication). A psychologist should have a postgraduate qualification in psychology. A therapist - well, anyone can call themselves a therapist, so you need to be careful and check out their background.
Please support our advertisers:
rio
20 yrs ago
thanks. so can anyone recommend a good psychologist/psychiatrist, basically someone who can help me "sort out" my past sh*t? i'm not really sure if i'd be comfortable with counsellors/therapists....
Please support our advertisers:
Psychologist - with extensive therapy background. Some counsellors are good, but I would ask alot of questions about their clinical experience and background. I have several friends who have gone to Resource Counselling (look in HK mag for ad) in Central and have been very happy with the results (and the prices are geared to income)
Please support our advertisers:
Please support our advertisers:
Psychiatrists have a reputation for using pills for "problem solving" whereas a psychologist is more about letting you purge yourself of suppressed feelings of guilt etc.. Melanie Bryan of Owens & Trodd is a qualified psychologist and hypnotherapist. I don't know what she charges but I would guess she is expemsive.
Please support our advertisers:
Fleur
20 yrs ago
There is a distinct difference between the two professions i.e. a psychiatrist is a medical practitional specializing in the diagnosis and treatment of mental illness whereas a psychologist tends to look at behaviour in a given context. Two very different professions and not one to confuse or even compare!
Please support our advertisers:
rio
20 yrs ago
so Fleur, i take it that my best option would be a psychologist?
Please support our advertisers:
Fleur
20 yrs ago
Judging from your very brief post a psychologist would seem to be the better option.
Please support our advertisers:
I cant recommend anyone in Hong Kong but I did go to see a psychiatrist at home for about two years. He can prescribe medication but it was up to me. I took meds for a while but they werent really for me. Mostly we just taked through my problems and where they came from - ie sh*tty past experiences. It really helped. I also went to see a counsellor for a time but I found the psychiatrist better. I think its just important to find someone you feel comfortable talking to - it took me some time to find that but it really helped overcome some hard stuff. good luck
Please support our advertisers:
rio
20 yrs ago
thanks for all your input...
Please support our advertisers:
When to See a Psychiatrist (if you suspect you suffer from one of these illnesses)
Depression
Attention deficit disorder
Alcohol and/or drug abuse
Anorexia
Anxiety
Bipolar disorder
Mania
http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/1029550/do_you_need_a_psychologist_or_a_psychiatrist.html?cat=68
When to See a Psychologist
Dissatisfaction with life
Fear of hurting yourself
Feelings of unhappiness
Coping with guilt or grief
Feelings of hopelessness and/or helplessness
Concern over having a mental illness
Losing touch with reality
Can anybody recommend a good psychiatrist in Hong Kong please?
Thank you in advance.
Please support our advertisers:
Resource counseling in Central is good. They gear their fees to your income. If they feel that you need the additional support of medication, they will refer you to an appropriate doctor.
Please support our advertisers:
You must be logged in to be able to reply.
Login now
Copy Link
Facebook
Gmail
Mail