Posted by
DeniseG
18 yrs ago
Sorry to start yet another thread on China adoptions, but I can't seem to find answers to my questions. My husband and I are Australia and NZ expats, in HKG since 2000. It seems that because we reside in HKG we can't adopt from China. If in fact we lived in China or in Australia, then we could adopt from China. This makes no sense to me. Can anyone shed any light or know if this has ever been done before.
My other question concerns US domestic adoptions. Does anyone know if we are in a position to adopt from the US?
Thanks for any info.
Please support our advertisers:
aemom
18 yrs ago
The problem with anyone coming from China to live in HK is the one-way permit. You probably could adopt a child but not be able to have it come to live in HK for several years. Lots of families are separated because of this unusual immigration feature.
Not sure about Aus & NZ, but Canadians have been adopting from the US for years. However, there are some changes now due to the Hague Convention (google it). This Canadian adoption website explains why they have halted US adoptions until the process is completed: http://www.sunriseadoption.com/adoptive_parents/WhatsHappeningInUS
From personal experience, I second cara's suggestion about local adoption!
Please support our advertisers:
Thanks aemom and dz, I'll follow up those contacts. We have an appointment with HK SWD in July to be put on the adoption list, but in the meantime we are looking at all options.
Thanks all.
Please support our advertisers:
HK has adoption agreement with China, India, Philipines and Thailand. Have you tried going through them?
Please support our advertisers:
Thanks Jassy - they were the ones that told me I could only adopt from China as an Australian if I lived in China or if I lived in Australia. Maybe its just beause its never been done before. If you can think of anything else, I'd be most grateful.
Cheers
Please support our advertisers:
Hi Denise,
We're in the same situation coming from England; we can adopt from China if we reside in England, but not whilst we live HK. But when I looked into the adoption process for living in England, it seemed to take alot longer than local adoption in HK. Infact it seems that we're lucky to be in HK whilst condsidering adoption, the Social Welfare Dept here seems to be more efficient than in other countries - although we're still at the beginning of the process!
Please support our advertisers:
Hi Julie - yes I think you're right re the SWD here in Hong Kong, just that they can take a while. We haven't even had our introductory meeting yet and I applied in January! I was just getting anxious and wanting to cover all bases. So frustrating re the China criteria, can't quite understand it myself. Wishing you the best of luck.
Cheers
Please support our advertisers:
Hey Julie - after many phone calls, to the we've just been CCAA and Australian Embassy in China, they've allowed us to adopt from China as Australians living in Hong Kong! Ground breaking stuff, eh! So you might like to phone the CCAA and have a chat. Good luck.
Please support our advertisers:
Hi DeniseG - that's excellent news! We're going to a Group Briefing Session for HK adoption at the SWD next month, so we'll see what they have to say first!
Please support our advertisers:
Just curious, but the HK adoption process is actually very efficient and much faster than China and other Countries. And alot cheaper. May I ask why you are choosing China over HK?
We just adopted here in HK (have had our daughter for 4 months now)
Please support our advertisers:
Jassy67 - congratualations! May I ask how long the assessment process took? Also, how long did it take to place you with a child once the assessment was approved? I just want to know how much of a wait we have.
Please support our advertisers:
julie2,
our process took longer than most, just over a year, as we were out of HK for 2 months (slowed things down) and some health issues as well. I have 2 friends who adopted and the process from first work shop to be approved took 8 months. We waited 4 1/2 months for a child, whereas 1 friend waited 4 months and 1 waited 8 months. If you want a girl under 6 months , the wait can be a little longer. Let me know if you have any other questions
Please support our advertisers:
Thanks for the info! The timing is quite encouraging, though of course I'm very impatient!
Please support our advertisers:
The process and cost is a big plus for the local adoption. And you don't pay a cent, until you have been matched with a child.
We are thinking of adopting another child here in a year or so.
Please support our advertisers:
aemom
18 yrs ago
DeniseG:
Getting permission from the CCAA and the Australian embassy in China only allows an adoption to take place. But it doesn't address the issue of a Chinese passport holder (the baby)immigrating to Hong Kong. That requires permission from another Chinese government department and also from the HK Immigration Department.
I have facilitated adoptions from China to Canada. The Canadian government allows the immigration process to run parallel to the adoption process. After the homestudy is completed and the application sent to the CCAA, adoptive parents can apply for immigration for the baby using "name unknown at present". When a match has been made. the application is amended to include the child's name. I'm sure that's how it happens in the US and probably Australia.
But, is this an option for HK parents adopting from China? Or will you find that one parent must stay in China for several months until the one-way permit is issued?
Please support our advertisers:
Hi DeniseG,
I'm not sure whether this was answered before but we found out that to adopt in the US you need to be a citizen, green card or worker permit is not enough.
We are in a similiar position to you.
We were told that we have to be in HK or even China for a year before we can apply to adopt but can you submit your application in that time?
J&B.
Please support our advertisers:
My wife and I looked into the adopting in Hong Kong. The Social Welfare Department did not make it very pleasing by presenting mentally challenging children as just like normal children. The statistics were not promising too. The mass majority of the children presented in Hong Kong are disabled.
Children available for adoption as at : 31 December 2011
# Characteristics of Children
-- --------------------------------------------------
0 Normal and healthy 0
10 Of relatively complicated family background
(e.g. abandoned children, birth parent was drug dependent, etc.)
18 Children aged 3 or above
12 With health issues
79 Disabled
119 Total
Please support our advertisers:
Hey does anyone know if the above info from Tedlem is accurate (still)?
i.e. is it possible to get a healthy adopted child under 3? Or most of the options about the disabled?
An awful thing to say but would only be interested in a physically healthy one. i.e. no major health problem or disability.
Don't care if "abandoned" or "complicated family background"! That's normal!
Please support our advertisers:
Also might add-- I am PR expat, wife is HK'er.
Please support our advertisers:
HI NOTAEUROPEAN.. although a long time ago did you ever get an answer to your question? We are in a similar situation ourselves
Please support our advertisers:
You must be logged in to be able to reply.
Login now
Copy Link
Facebook
Gmail
Mail